| David=Gigem | 5 | JB=Dream Team | 4 | Mike=Cowboys | 3 | Scott=Longhorns | 7 | |||||||||
| Starting Lineup | Pos | Team | Starting Lineup | Pos | Team | Starting Lineup | Pos | Team | Starting Lineup | Pos | Team | |||||
| 2 | Donovan McNabb | QB | Philadelphia | 7 | Jake Delhomme | QB | Carolina | 2 | Matt Hasselbeck | QB | Seattle | 7 | Dante Culpepper | QB | Miami | |
| 1 | Edgerrin James | RB | Arizona | 1 | Rudi Johnson | RB | Cincinnati | 1 | Shaun Alexander | RB | Seattle | 1 | Steven Jackson | RB | St. Louis | |
| 8 | Dominic Rhodes | RB | Indianapolis | 2 | Carnell Williams | RB | Tampa Bay | 5 | Julius Jones | RB | Dallas | 2 | Ronnie Brown | RB | Miami | |
| 3 | Randy Moss | WR | Oakland | 6 | Terry Glenn | WR | Dallas | 3 | Marvin Harrison | WR | Indianapolis | 3 | Torry Holt | WR | St. Louis | |
| 4 | Antonio Gates | WR | San Diego | 10 | Keenan McCardell | WR | San Diego | 8 | Joey Galloway | WR | Tampa Bay | 4 | Larry Fitzgerald | WR | Arizona | |
| 7 | Jason Elam | K | Denver | 4 | Neil Rackers | K | Arizona | 7 | Adam Vinatieri | K | Indianapolis | 5 | David Akers | K | Philadelphia | |
| 5 | Colts | DEF | Indianapolis | 3 | Panthers | DEF | Carolina | 4 | Steelers | DEF | Pittsburgh | 6 | Cowboys | DEF | Dallas | |
| Spare Lineup | Spare Lineup | Spare Lineup | Spare Lineup | |||||||||||||
| 10 | Michael Vick | QB | Atlanta | 14 | Rex Grossman | QB | Chicago | 9 | Kurt Warner | QB | Arizona | 10 | Brett Farve | QB | Green Bay | |
| 11 | Marion Barber | RB | Dallas | 5 | DeShaun Foster | RB | Carolina | 6 | Reggie Bush | RB | New Orleans | 9 | Frank Gore | RB | San Francisco | |
| 12 | DeAngelo Williams | RB | Carolina | 12 | Ahman Green | RB | Green Bay | 12 | Chester Taylor | RB | Minnesota | 11 | Jamel Lewis | RB | Baltimore | |
| 6 | T.J. Houshmandzaden | WR | Cincinnati | 11 | Drew Bennett | WR | Tennessee | 10 | Darrell Jackson | WR | Seattle | 12 | Tony Gonzales | WR | Kansas City | |
| 9 | Roy Williams | WR | Detroit | 13 | Matt Jones | WR | Jacksonville | 11 | Andrea Johnson | WR | Houston | 13 | Lee Evans | WR | Buffalo | |
| 13 | Nate Kaeding | K | San Diego | 8 | Shayne Graham | K | Cincinnati | 14 | Olino Mare | K | Miami | 14 | Ryan Longwell | K | Minnesota | |
| 14 | Packers | DEF | Green Bay | 9 | Bengals | DEF | Cincinnati | 13 | Falcons | DEF | Atlanta | 8 | Buccaneers | DEF | Tampa Bay | |
| Russell=Fisherman | 2 | Jason=offinthewoods | 8 | Jeff=Krunks | 6 | Jim=Panthers | 9 | |||||||||
| Starting Lineup | Pos | Team | Starting Lineup | Pos | Team | Starting Lineup | Pos | Team | Starting Lineup | Pos | Team | |||||
| 5 | Drew Bledsoe | QB | Dallas | 2 | Tom Brady | QB | New England | 3 | Marc Bulger | QB | St. Louis | 1 | Payton Manning | QB | Indianapolis | |
| 1 | LaDainian Tomlinson | RB | San Diego | 3 | Willis McGahee | RB | Buffalo | 1 | Tiki Barber | RB | New York G | 2 | Clinton Portis | RB | Washington | |
| 3 | Brian Westbrook | RB | Philadelphia | 4 | Ron Dayne | RB | Houston | 4 | Corery Dillion | RB | New England | 4 | Lendale White | RB | Tennessee | |
| 2 | Terrell Owens | WR | Dallas | 5 | Plaxico Burress | WR | New York G | 2 | Chad Johnson | WR | Cincinnati | 3 | Santana Moss | WR | Washington | |
| 4 | Hines Ward | WR | Pittsburgh | 6 | Javon Walker | WR | Denver | 5 | Laveranues Coles | WR | New York J | 5 | Reggie Wayne | WR | Indianapolis | |
| 7 | Mike Vanderjagt | K | Dallas | 7 | John Kasey | K | Carolina | 7 | Matt Stover | K | Baltimore | 8 | Jeff Wilkins | K | St. Louis | |
| 6 | Ravens | DEF | Baltimore | 1 | Bears | DEF | Chicago | 6 | Saints | DEF | New Orleans | 7 | Redskins | DEF | Washington | |
| Spare Lineup | Spare Lineup | Spare Lineup | Spare Lineup | |||||||||||||
| 11 | MarK Brunell | QB | Washington | 12 | Kerry Collins | QB | Tennessee | 8 | Steve McNair | QB | Baltimore | 9 | Drew Brees | QB | New Orleans | |
| 8 | Fred Taylor | RB | Jacksonville | 8 | Kevin Jones | RB | Detroit | 13 | Deuce McAllister | RB | New Orleans | 6 | Thomas Jones | RB | Chicago | |
| 13 | Joseph Addai | RB | Indianapolis | 9 | Mike Bell | RB | Denver | 14 | T.J. Duckett | RB | Washington | 10 | Chris Brown | RB | Tennessee | |
| 9 | Jeremy Shockey | WR | New York G | 10 | Dieon Branch | WR | New England | 9 | Rod Smith | WR | Denver | 14 | Joe Horn | WR | New Orleans | |
| 10 | Jason Witten | WR | Dallas | 11 | Keyshawn Johnson | WR | Carolina | 11 | Antonio Bryant | WR | San Francisco | 12 | Amani Toomer | WR | New York G | |
| 14 | John Hall | K | Washington | 13 | Sebastian Janikowski | K | Oakland | 12 | Lawrence Tynes | K | Kansas City | 13 | Josh Brown | K | Seattle | |
| 12 | Eagles | DEF | Philadelphia | 14 | Patroits | DEF | New England | 10 | Seahawks | DEF | Seattle | 11 | Jaguars | DEF | Jacksonville | |
| Jeff=49ers | 1 | Jo Paul=Lenny's Team | 10 | |||||||||||||
| Starting Lineup | Pos | Team | Spare Lineup | Starting Lineup | Pos | Team | Spare Lineup | |||||||||
| 2 | Eli Manning | QB | New York G | 9 | Jake Plummer | QB | Denver | 1 | Carlson Palmer | QB | Cincinnati | 8 | Trent Green | QB | Kansas City | |
| 1 | Larry Johnson | RB | Kansas City | 7 | Warrick Dunn | RB | Atlanta | 2 | Lamont Jordon | RB | Oakland | 13 | Kevin Barlow | RB | New York J | |
| 4 | Willie Parker | RB | Pittsburgh | 13 | Mike Anderson | RB | Baltimore | 6 | Reuben Droughns | RB | Cleveland | 14 | Vernon Haynes | RB | Pittsburgh | |
| 3 | Steve Smith | WR | Carolina | 10 | Donte Stallworth | WR | Philadelphia | 3 | Chris Chambers | WR | Miami | 9 | Eddie Kennison | WR | Kansas City | |
| 5 | Anquan Boldin | WR | Arizona | 11 | Derrick Mason | WR | Baltimore | 5 | Donald Driver | WR | Green Bay | 11 | Jerry Porter | WR | Oakland | |
| 8 | Jay Feely | K | New York G | 12 | Jeff Reed | K | Pittsburgh | 7 | Stephen Gostkowski | K | New England | 12 | Rian Lindell | K | Buffalo | |
| 6 | Giants | DEF | New York | 14 | Vikings | DEF | Minnesota | 4 | Broncos | DEF | Denver | 10 | Dolphins | DEF | Miami | |